I suppose in the eyes of some that makes him a journalist. After all, he founded a newspaper and he writes. On another hand, a 12-year-old girl who keeps a diary (or journal) could be called a journalist.
A real journalist is meticulous, accurate, takes clear notes or records conversations (with permission). If a real journalist reports on an interview they are careful to faithfully report what was said, in the context in which it was said.
In Scalfari’s case, he fails on all these points. He doesn’t record or take notes, but simply engages in a conversation and then writes his impressions and calls it an interview. It is a little like having Picasso walk through a courtroom, do a cubist work from memory and call it court reporting.
Perhaps I should give Scalfari a break in light of his advanced age: nearly 94. But I think he ought to know better and be more responsible.
In his most recent interview with the Holy Father, Scalfari reported that the Pope had doubts about the existence of Hell. Despite how often the Pope has spoken of Hell and how it is a place to be avoided, social media went crazy and the Vatican had to issue an admonition not to trust what Scalfari writes.
This is nothing new. It happens every time the Pope talks to this guy. So some people wonder why Francis doesn’t find someone a little more reliable to talk with.
I don’t know for certain, but my guess is that the Pope is hoping to create a meaningful dialogue with the journalist – an adamant atheist – to come around to the faith before he kicks the bucket of printer’s ink and finds out Hell is real.
Jesus dialogued with some rather sordid souls and saved a high percentage. Of course, none of them were reaching a large readership.
As for the existence of Hell, the Church says there is such a place and I agree. I’m sure many people – including noted theologians – could debate its nature. Dante wrote a bit about it. Artists have created countless images.
I don’t believe the popular idea of it being a place where a guy with a pitchfork jumps around in red long underwear. But some people believe it is personally created to fit the individual sinner. If that is true – and with me being a frequent critic of the news media – I hope I don’t end up being interviewed for all eternity by Scalfari, with every word I speak being misquoted and presented out of context. And I dread he would be wearing red undies.